cinema 1: the movement-image
I got the book The Transcendental Style in Film recently and talked to a friend about it, which led to me telling her about my deep dives into Deleuze’s cinema theory. She then recommended I share my thoughts and I thought “what better place than here?”.
This will be a two-parter, with the first part dealing with the movement-image and the second part dealing with the time-image. If you want to read the originals, you can find them here: Cinema 1: The Movement-Image & Cinema 2: The Time-Image.
. . .
In the book Cinema 1: The Movement-Image, Gilles Deleuze sets out to build a framework to understand how meaning is constructed through sequential images. He was not a director nor a film historian, and as such, his perspective is neither a technical one (concerning shot length, framing or angles) nor strictly historical one, but rather a philosophical one that attempts to create a dynamic semiotic system of cinema.
Working off of Henri Bergson’s ideas on movement and duration, he splits film history into three fundamental phases – the proto-cinema, the cinema of the movement-image and the cinema of the time-image. In this part 1, I will explore the movement-image.
. . .
Proto-cinema exhibits the technological ability to create cinema, but also the lack of the cinematic technique and is the phase in which it begins to develop. The first, crucial step in this development for Deleuze is the movement of the camera iself. The first films which were purely technical demonstrations – such as Lumiére’s films – all display a stationary fixed camera. Some cuts can already be seen in Meliés’ work, but the camera remains largely fixed, and it’s simply as if the scenario changes between the shots. But it is through progressive change like this, that the camera first starts moving, and later that movement is abstracted through the cut, allowing for an expansion of the frame and the permeation of movement and time into film – these are the first montage techniques – the American organic montage, the Soviet dialectic montage, the French quantitative montage and the German intensive montage.
Through these, and especially through the organic American montage, we witness the development of the movement-image, which creates meaning in film by appealing to the intuition of the human body, a schema which Deleuze calls the sensory-motor schema. In this system, there are three privileged instants: the instant of perception, the instant of affection (emotional reaction) and the instant of action. Through these three instants, meaning is created.
A character perceives a situation or circumstance, which causes in their psyche some affect, which in turn leads them to take some action which changes the situation or circumstance. These narrative beats function at the scale of individual shots, or even as segments of shots.
This system of intuitions derived from Bergson is aligned with most intuitions from other disciplines, such as acting, animation or even fiction writing. From these three instants, three broad types of movement-images are created: the perception-image, the affection-image and the action-image. These work circularly, each leading from one to the other, and thus elaborating through their circularity a series of actions that create meaning, visually. Due to their nature, there are some rough associations that can be drawn between these images and technical aspects of them, but these are neither direct nor strict, and must be adapted to each scene and narrative.
- Perception-images show situations and are typically wide shots.
- Affection-images show emotions and are typically close-ups.
- Action-images show actions and are typically medium shots.
Bergson’s theory however, realizes that the human intuition exists in multiplicities and uncertainty, and as such another kind of image can also enter the scene: the mental-image. This subset of the movement-image explores precisely the complications and uncertainty that dwells within the sensory-motor schema, and by doing so, stretches its ability to create meaning, demonstrating that the movement-image does not hold the monopoly on the cinematic image, and will ultimately come to be challenged by precisely this deconstruction of itself.
. . .
And this is my general summary of Gilles Deleuze’s Cinema 1: The Movement-Image. While I am an academic in this field and I hope this summary helps anyone in need of understanding these texts, I do sincerely recommend reading the original, as it is quite dense and talks about a lot of material that I couldn’t get into due to the brevity of this summary. Regardless, I hope this satisfies your nerdy need for film theory.